INDIANAPOLIS — Senate President Pro Tem Chris Garten on Tuesday accused Democrats of using “lawfare” to block him from taking office.
Garten, a Republican from Charlestown, is the apparent winner of the Senate District 46 election by 297 votes. Clark County election officials are investigating technical problems involving several voting machines.
Democrats on Monday obtained a court order that blocked certification of the election and prevented Garten from taking office. The order threatened to disrupt Senate operations because Republican senators had already chosen Garten as the next president pro tem, and he had begun exercising the office’s duties, including assigning committee chairs.
The Senate president pro tem assigns bills to committees and decides which measures advance to a floor vote. The House speaker has a similar role in the House.
Around noon Tuesday, the Indiana Supreme Court issued an order allowing Garten to take the oath of office with the rest of the Senate. The full Senate then unanimously elected him president pro tem.
After the ceremonial session, Garten said he had formally requested a recount of his election. Losing candidates typically request recounts, but Garten said voters deserve transparency and that he remains confident in the results.
“An order preventing a senator-elect from taking office raises fundamental questions about the separation of powers, about the authority of our courts and the constitutional responsibility of the Indiana Senate to judge the qualifications of its members,” he said.
Garten’s request covers four precincts in his district. Indiana Democratic Party leaders said the request is too narrow to provide a complete accounting of the vote.
In a brief statement, executive director Evan Robbins said, “Making sure every legal vote was counted accurately when both sides agree there were discrepancies is not “lawfare”. Sen. Garten’s recount request covers only four precincts. There were more issues throughout Clark County and Hoosiers deserve a full accounting of votes with a full recount.”
If the recount changes the election results, the Senate would have to elect a new presiding officer. The highest-ranking Republican after Garten is Sen. Eric Koch, R-Bedford, the majority floor leader.
Election officials have until January to address the court order. Lawmakers will not return to the Statehouse until then.